Has Snapchat Given Up the Ghost?

Has Snapchat Given Up the Ghost?

Big Ideas

View More
October 17 2018
Big Ideas

In honour of Halloween, gather around the campfire with us for a true marketing horror story. A tale of plummeting stocks, vanishing users, and damning incantations by market analysts and Kylie Jenner. This is the story of SNAP Inc. Read on…if you dare.


It was a dark and stormy night…

On October 1st, the Dow slammed its doors on stocks for SNAP Inc, hitting an all-time low of $8.23 per share. Stocks for the company had been in a free-fall since February, just a year after the American technology company had gone public with it’s “in-the-moment” photo sharing platform. Since the previous July, SNAP had lost 11 key staffers – and now former Vurb CEO Bobby Lo, whom SNAP had acquired just two years ago with a $114.5 million four-year vesting retention deal, was politely pulling out of the company’s day-to-day operations and into a vaguely defined “advisory role”.




The Blair Rich Project

SNAP’s talent retention issues had become an obvious problem to investors. On September 5, BTIG analyst Rich Greenfield cast a heavy stone on SNAP’s business acumen.

“We are tired of Snapchat’s excuses for missing numbers and are no longer willing to give management ‘time’ to figure out monetization,” Greenfield said.

A week later, a damning report by Business Insider stated that Snapchat’s user base had begun declining worldwide, with 300 million daily users falling off the wagon. This could only mean advertisers were sure to follow. This was in direct contrast to SNAP’s reported ad revenue forecasted for 2019, which showed a $1.25 billion dollar increase. Plummeting ad prices appeared to have coaxed in hesitant marketers, like a group of foolish teenagers heading off into the foggy woods.

“We have been disappointed in SNAP’s product evolution (as have users) and see no reason to believe this will change,” said Greenfield, cursing the company with a “Sell” rating and a new forecast of $5 per share.


Kylie’s Kiss of Death

This grim prognosis, coupled with echoes of cosmetics/social media mogul and Kardashian family member Kylie Jenner’s tweet which threatened the relevance of the platform, did not help SNAP’s image.



Jenner’s tweet has previously been attributed to a $1.3 billion dollar drop in SNAP’s market value back in February, just after 2018 values peaked at $20 per share. The validity of the correlation between Jenner’s tweet and SNAP’s decline was controversial, but as it often goes – on the internet, what people think is more powerful than the facts.


Kylie Jenner and Snapchat

Who will survive?

From a marketing strategy perspective, our sixth sense tells us that allocating a significant digital marketing budget into Snapchat, SNAP’s core product, will be a grind house B-movie at best and a full-on zombie apocalypse at worst. From a user perspective, not only have users declined and ad congestion increased, users (mainly female Gen Z'ers in the 18-24 age group) have the option to skip ads with no minimum runtime.

Instead, social media strategies for most businesses should stick to safe-haven platforms like Instagram, whose user growth and engagement rates continue to climb steadily. Facebook and YouTube continue to slay the competition in advertising potential – with Facebook’s robust targeting tools and reasonable ad service costs, and YouTube’s incredible organic SEO power.

Furthermore, brands should not discount the value of a solid SEO and inbound marketing strategy, coupled with consistent, high-quality content. Focus on using social media during moments of consideration; when browsing, chances are your audience is consuming inspiration without explicit intent to buy. The highest conversion potential is still on Google, so if you’re investing in Snapchat’s interruption-style ad service but haven’t yet padded your website with SEO-friendly content, you may have your priorities backwards.


Social Media Marketing


Don’t get lost in the woods

A mistake some brands make is pouring money into a social media strategy based on whether they think they should be there, rather than taking the time to study their audience’s social media habits and setting realistic KPIs based on the potential value of the platform’s usership. The truth is, very few brands fill their treat bags based on social media attribution. Most social media campaigns sit at the top of the sales funnel, at the awareness stage, or nurture relationships with existing customers at the funnel’s end.

Where Snapchat fails to make the cut for brands is with its focus on messaging, where ads are literally forced into the picture as people are trying to communicate with close friends.

So, what about Instagram stories?

Data from this June shows twice as many users engage with Instagram’s Stories feature, and Instagram’s IGTV feature provides an enhanced version for longer-form in-the-moment content. Instagram also has the benefit of offering limited-time content served to relevant audiences with the creative potential of a core account featuring evergreen videos and stills. 


When will the nightmare end?

Compared to Snapchat’s geofilters – the choice is obvious. Go with the hero platform that’s going to survive until the end of the show, and rest in peace.



Thanks for reading!
Enjoyed this article? Sign up for The Summit - our monthly Newsletter.
Say Hello On: Instagram | Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube


Sign up to get the latest content!

If you wish to receive information from Sherpa relevant to you and/or your organization going forward, please provide your first name, email address, and consent.

You may withdraw your consent at any time at the following address below or by clicking unsubscribe.

Sherpa Marketing Inc. Attn: Privacy Officer
500 - 211 Bannatyne Ave. Winnipeg, MB. R3B 3P2, Canada

1-888-447-7727       info@sherpamarketing.ca